Heat Pump Myths - The Truth About Air Source Heat Pumps
Updated: 2 days ago

Air source heat pumps are becoming an increasingly popular alternative to traditional gas and oil boilers, offering homeowners an opportunity to heat their properties more efficiently while reducing their reliance on fossil fuels.
However, despite their growing popularity, there are still plenty of questions surrounding the technology. Are they noisy? Will they actually keep your home warm during winter? Are they expensive to run? And do you need planning permission to have one installed?
It's understandable that homeowners want to get the facts before investing in a new heating system. Unfortunately, there's also a lot of misinformation out there, which can make it difficult to know what to believe.
So, we're separating fact from fiction and looking at eight of the most common air source heat pump myths and misconceptions.
What are the myths about heat pumps?
Myth 1: Air source heat pumps are noisy
The reality: Modern air source heat pumps are designed to operate quietly, and a correctly positioned unit should not cause significant disturbance.
One of the biggest concerns homeowners have is the noise produced by an air source heat pump.
Because the system has an outdoor unit containing a fan and compressor, it's natural to assume that it will be noisy, particularly if it's positioned close to a neighbouring property.
However, modern heat pumps have been designed with noise reduction in mind. While they do produce some sound when operating, manufacturers have made considerable improvements to ensure that units run as quietly as possible.
The amount of noise produced will depend on the make and model, how hard the system is working and where the unit is positioned.
A professional installation is particularly important here. The outdoor unit should be carefully positioned, with consideration given to neighbouring properties, bedroom windows and potential vibration.
Government research has also found that noise complaints are relatively uncommon and are often associated with poor installation practices.
The takeaway: Air source heat pumps aren't completely silent, but noise isn't a reason to rule one out. Choosing the right unit and having it professionally installed makes a significant difference.
Myth 2: You always need planning permission to install an air source heat pump
The reality: In many cases, air source heat pumps can be installed under permitted development rights without requiring a full planning application.
Another common misconception is that installing an air source heat pump involves a complicated planning permission process.
The good news is that this isn't necessarily the case.
In England, air source heat pumps generally benefit from permitted development rights, meaning homeowners can install one without applying for planning permission, provided the relevant conditions and requirements are met.
Planning rules were relaxed in May 2025, making installations more accessible for many homeowners. Changes included removing the previous one-metre boundary restriction and increasing the permitted size of certain units.
However, there are exceptions. Additional permissions or restrictions may apply if your property is listed, situated in certain designated areas or doesn't meet the permitted development conditions.
It's also worth remembering that planning regulations differ across England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland.
A reputable installer should be able to help you understand the requirements that apply to your property before installation begins.
The takeaway: Planning permission isn't always necessary, but it's important to check the rules before committing to an installation.
Myth 3: Air source heat pumps don't work when it's cold outside
The reality: Air source heat pumps are designed to operate throughout the year, including during freezing winter temperatures.
This is probably one of the most persistent myths surrounding heat pump technology.
If a heat pump takes warmth from the outside air, surely it won't work when temperatures drop below freezing?
Actually, it will.
Even when the outside temperature feels extremely cold, there is still thermal energy present in the air. An air source heat pump extracts this energy and uses a refrigeration cycle to increase its temperature before transferring it into your home's heating system.
Modern heat pumps are specifically designed to operate in cold climates, and many models can continue working in temperatures well below freezing.
It's true that efficiency can decrease as outdoor temperatures fall because the system has to work harder to extract heat. However, this doesn't mean it stops working.
The important thing is ensuring that the heat pump is correctly sized and designed for your property and its heating requirements.
The takeaway: Cold British winters aren't a barrier to owning an air source heat pump. With the right system design, your home can stay warm throughout the year.
Myth 4: Air source heat pumps are inefficient compared to traditional boilers
The reality: Heat pumps can be significantly more efficient than conventional gas and oil boilers.
At first glance, it might seem strange to suggest that a heating system powered by electricity could be more efficient than a boiler burning gas or oil.
However, the difference comes down to how the technology works.
A traditional boiler generates heat by burning fuel. An air source heat pump, on the other hand, transfers existing heat from the outside air into your home.
This means it doesn't need to generate all its heat from the electricity it consumes.
In fact, for every unit of electricity used, a well-designed heat pump can typically deliver around three to four units of heat.
This is known as its Coefficient of Performance (CoP).
For example, a heat pump with a CoP of 3 produces three units of heat for every unit of electricity consumed.
Of course, actual performance varies depending on outdoor temperatures, system design, heating controls and the temperature at which the system operates.
The key is getting the design right from the beginning.
The takeaway: Air source heat pumps are highly efficient heating systems, and their ability to transfer rather than generate heat is what makes them so effective.
Myth 5: Air source heat pumps will always increase your energy bills
The reality: Running costs depend on your existing heating system, electricity tariff, property and how efficiently the heat pump operates.
This is understandably one of the biggest questions homeowners ask.
Electricity is more expensive per unit than gas in the UK, so surely replacing a gas boiler with an electric heating system will result in higher bills?
Not necessarily.
Although heat pumps use electricity, they can produce several units of heat for every unit of electricity consumed. This high efficiency can help offset the difference in fuel prices.
However, it's important to be realistic. An air source heat pump won't automatically save every household money.
Your potential savings will depend on several factors, including:
The heating system you're replacing.
The efficiency of your new heat pump.
The insulation and heat loss of your property.
Your electricity tariff.
How your heating system is controlled.
Whether your radiators are appropriately sized.
Switching to a specialist heat pump electricity tariff can also help reduce running costs, particularly where cheaper off-peak electricity is available.
For some households, running costs may be similar to a modern gas boiler, while others replacing older electric, oil or LPG heating systems may see more significant savings.
It's always worth asking for a realistic running cost assessment before making a decision.
The takeaway: Heat pumps can help reduce energy bills, but savings depend on the individual property and energy tariff. A properly designed system is essential.
Myth 6: You need underfloor heating to have an air source heat pump
The reality: Air source heat pumps work perfectly well with radiators, and underfloor heating isn't essential.
Another misconception is that homeowners must completely replace their existing heating system before installing a heat pump.
This simply isn't true.
Although underfloor heating can work particularly well with heat pumps, existing radiators can often be retained.
Heat pumps generally operate at lower flow temperatures than traditional boilers. This means radiators need to have sufficient surface area to transfer enough heat into the rooms.
In some properties, existing radiators will be suitable. In others, certain radiators may need to be upgraded to larger or higher-output models.
A proper heat loss survey and heating system assessment will help determine what's needed.
The aim is to ensure that every room receives enough heat while allowing the heat pump to operate as efficiently as possible.
The takeaway: You don't need underfloor heating to enjoy the benefits of an air source heat pump. Radiators can work very effectively when the system is designed correctly.
Myth 7: Air source heat pumps are only suitable for new-build properties
The reality: Heat pumps can be installed in many different property types, including older homes.
It's easy to assume that air source heat pumps are only suitable for modern, well-insulated new-build homes.
While newer properties can offer certain advantages, older homes shouldn't automatically be ruled out.
A heat pump can work in a wide range of properties, including detached houses, semi-detached homes, bungalows and some older or traditionally constructed buildings.
The important consideration is how much heat your property loses and whether the heating system can deliver enough warmth to compensate.
Insulation improvements can help reduce heat loss and improve overall efficiency, but a home doesn't necessarily need to be completely renovated before a heat pump can be considered.
Every property is different, which is why a detailed assessment is so important.
An experienced installer can assess the building, calculate its heating requirements and recommend any improvements needed to achieve the best performance.
The takeaway: Don't assume your property is unsuitable simply because it's older. The right assessment will help establish whether an air source heat pump is a practical option.
Myth 8: Air source heat pumps are complicated to use and require constant maintenance
The reality: Once properly installed and commissioned, most heat pumps are straightforward to operate.
Many homeowners worry that moving away from a traditional boiler will mean learning a completely new and complicated heating system.
In reality, modern heat pumps are designed to make everyday heating as simple as possible.
Most systems have user-friendly controls that allow you to set heating schedules, adjust temperatures and manage your hot water.
Unlike traditional boilers, which are often switched on and off according to demand, heat pumps generally work most efficiently when maintaining a consistent indoor temperature.
This might mean making a few adjustments to how you use your heating, but most homeowners quickly become accustomed to the difference.
Like any heating system, an air source heat pump needs routine servicing and occasional maintenance to ensure it continues operating efficiently.
Keeping the outdoor unit clear of leaves and debris and arranging regular professional checks will help maintain performance over time.
The takeaway: Heat pumps don't need constant attention. With the right controls, installation and maintenance, they're designed to provide reliable, straightforward home heating.
Are air source heat pumps worth it?
Hopefully, we've cleared up some of the most common myths surrounding air source heat pumps.
While no heating system is perfect for every property, heat pumps offer an efficient and increasingly accessible alternative to traditional fossil fuel heating.
They can work in cold weather, operate quietly when installed correctly, heat homes using existing radiators and potentially help households reduce their energy bills.
The most important factor is ensuring that the system is properly designed around your property and your household's heating requirements.
Before making a decision, it's worth speaking to an experienced installer who can assess your home, explain your options and provide a realistic picture of installation costs and potential running costs.
Thinking about making the switch to an air source heat pump?
Whether you're replacing an existing gas or oil boiler or simply exploring more energy-efficient ways to heat your home, we're here to help.
Get in touch with our team to discuss your property, find out whether an air source heat pump is right for you and take the first step towards a more efficient heating system.
